The Midpoint Moves

Poetry by Britt Wolfe Author

Read more poetry by Britt Wolfe

You keep calling it
the centre

as though the centre
were a place.

As though someone drove
a brass marker
into the earth

and said:

Here.

This is reasonable.

As though moderation
were longitude,

measurable,
permanent,

immune
to whoever happens
to be standing
at its edges.

But the midpoint moves.

That is mathematics.

And somehow
you have mistaken it
for morality.

If one person says

everyone deserves
the same rights

and another says

some people
deserve fewer,

the reasonable position
is not to ask

how many rights
we might remove

before everyone
calms down.

If one person says

democracy requires
institutions capable
of restraining power

and another says

power should be free
to restrain
the institutions,

there is no wisdom
in meeting
between them.

If one person says

these people
belong here

and another says

they do not,

halfway
is not tolerance.

It is exclusion
with better manners.

And yet

this is how
you govern.

The Right moves right.

You move right
to meet them.

They move again.

You call for compromise.

They discover
there is somewhere else
you are willing to go.

And so they go there.

Again.

Again.

Again.

Until yesterday's extreme
becomes today's debate,

today's debate
becomes tomorrow's compromise,

and tomorrow's compromise
becomes the new centre

from which you congratulate yourself
for refusing
to move further.

Not yet.

This is how
the unacceptable
becomes negotiable.

Not all at once.

Not usually.

It enters
as a question.

Should we reconsider?

Then a concern.

People are worried.

Then a debate.

Both sides deserve to be heard.

Then a policy.

We have to be realistic.

Then one morning

someone points
to the position
you would once
have condemned

and calls it

moderate.

And you stand beside it

looking terribly pleased
with yourself

for preventing
something worse.

But worse
keeps coming.

That is the part
your politics
cannot solve.

Because your definition
of courage

is standing halfway
between where we are

and wherever
the most unreasonable person
in the room
would like us to go.

You call this balance.

But a scale
does not become balanced

because you keep adding weight
to the lighter side.

At some point

you have simply
changed the measurement.

At some point

the centre
is no longer holding.

It is following.

And I need you
to understand

that refusing
the furthest extreme

does not make
everything before it
reasonable.

Cruelty
does not become compassion

because someone else
proposed greater cruelty.

Authoritarianism
does not become democracy

because someone else
wanted dictatorship.

Discrimination
does not become moderation

because someone else
demanded persecution.

A slightly smaller injustice

is still
an injustice.

A quieter violation

is still
a violation.

And a government
that permits

what it once promised
to prevent

does not become courageous
because another government
would permit more.

There must be
a point

at which you stop asking

How far can we move
and still call ourselves
the centre?

and begin asking

What should never
have moved at all?

Because some things
are not bargaining positions.

A person's humanity
is not a bargaining position.

Equal protection
is not a bargaining position.

The rule of law
is not a bargaining position.

Free expression
is not a bargaining position.

The right to disagree
without becoming
an enemy of the state

is not a bargaining position.

Democracy cannot survive
as an endless negotiation

over how much democracy
we are prepared
to surrender.

There are moments
when moderation
is wisdom.

There are disputes
where compromise
is the only way
human beings
can live together.

There are questions
on which reasonable people
can stand very far apart

and still
be reasonable.

This is not
an argument
against the centre.

It is an argument
against using the centre

as an excuse
not to recognize
the edge.

Because when the edge
keeps moving,

standing halfway
is movement.

When the unacceptable
keeps advancing,

compromise
can become permission.

And when people
who intend to dismantle
the boundaries of democracy

tell you exactly
what they intend to do,

your responsibility
is not to calculate

the most moderate version
of their demand.

It is to say

no.

No,

we will not become
slightly less equal.

No,

we will not become
slightly less free.

No,

we will not make
a vulnerable person's life
slightly more dangerous

because someone louder
has demanded
it become unbearable.

No,

we will not rename
capitulation

consensus.

There is nothing
radical

about refusing
to abandon a principle

simply because someone else
has abandoned theirs.

And perhaps
that is what
you have forgotten.

The centre
is not inherently good.

The middle
is not inherently moral.

Halfway
is only halfway.

Its virtue depends entirely

on what
it stands between.

Stand halfway
between mercy
and cruelty,

and you have not invented
moderation.

You have permitted
some cruelty.

Stand halfway
between equality
and supremacy,

and you have not created
consensus.

You have created
a hierarchy.

Stand halfway
between democracy
and authoritarianism,

and history
will not remember you

as the reasonable people
who kept everyone calm.

It will remember

that the line moved.

And moved.

And moved.

And every time it did,

you moved
with it,

stood carefully
in the new middle,

looked back
at the distance
we had travelled,

and called yourself

the centre.

Keep My Words Alive

If this poem has stayed with you, you can help keep my words alive. Every bit of support helps carry the stories forward.


WHERE WORDS MEET MORNING LIGHT
BEGIN EACH Week WITH SOMETHING BEAUTIFUL

Every Sunday, at 11:11AM, I send a poem — sometimes soft, sometimes devastating, always truly felt.

💚 Subscribe now to read and breathe and feel along with me 💚


Poetry by Britt Wolfe:

Britt Wolfe

Britt Wolfe writes emotionally devastating fiction with the precision of a heart surgeon and the recklessness of someone who definitely shouldn’t be trusted with sharp objects. Her stories explore love, loss, and the complicated mess of being human. If you enjoy books that punch you in the feelings and then politely offer you a Band-Aid, you’re in the right place.

https://bio.site/brittwolfeauthor
Next
Next

Your Empty Message